Steve Maxwell: "Shelly is correct of course. The actual notated rhythm of the ride beat is absolutely simple. However, the trick is how the drummer interprets that rhythm."
Read moreThe Legend of Tommy Thomas (1901-1995)
"You see, Tommy knew everyone who was somebody in the business. All of the players: Gene Krupa, Lionel Hampton, Davey Tough, and everybody that I mentioned before; all of those people knew who Tommy was. All of the manufacturers knew Tommy. Tommy is mentioned in the 1933 Ludwig catalog, and notably in the 1937 WFL catalog for using the new Ludwig Speed King pedal. Tommy had an endorsement with Zildjian, Gretsch and also later with Slingerland. Tommy was also best of friends with William F. Ludwig, Sr. I think that’s why he (WFL) gave Tommy those two beautiful Ludwig drums, i.e., the 6.5 X 14”” engraved Ludwig Black Beauty and 5 X 14” Super-Sensitive.
Editor's note - It should be mentioned that the book that Tommy Thomas collaborated on with Ray Bauduc, Dixieland Drumming Instruction, is considered the first drum set instruction book ever published. This alone makes Tommy one of the most important persons in the early history of the drum set. I have included a picture of the front of that book. I have a copy myself and it is one of my prized possessions. I never completely understood why the drum set is played the way it is until I read that book. It is mind boggling that Tommy watched the entire growth of drum set drumming from the early pioneers like Baby Dodds, Zutty Singleton, and Ray Bauduc all the way up to Elvin Jones, Terry Bozzio, Vinnie Colaiuta and all the modern leading edge players who are still pushing the envelope.
Read moreSteve Jordan: One Extraordinary Life
"My dad said to me, "If you can learn how to play Art Blakey's "Blues March," you can play anything."
Read moreMike Clark: Words of Wisdom, Part 9
Many musicians… Myself included - would not have a career today if not for the genius and innovation of Tony Williams. Many who don't know who he is have careers because of Tony, and not just drummers. His musical voice was like a war cry to those of us who were young when he hit the scene. It spoke to us on every level, social, political and cultural.
He changed music and drumming forever in several different genres. Always seeking, and pushing the envelope… Always challenging everything.
Reflections on Shelly Manne - Ch. 7
Not So Modern Drummer columnist David Barsalou asked internationally recognized drummers – Hal Blaine, Aaron Kennedy, Shawn Meehan, Bobby T Torello, and Jay Wood to share their ideas and opinions on the following quote attributed to Shelly Manne.
Shelly Manne said...
"The ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play".
Reflections On Shelly Manne - chapter six
Shelly Manne (1920-1984) - Historically important jazz drummer most associated with the ‘West Coast Jazz’ style. Shelly was so versatile that he also played on hundreds of Hollywood movie, and television soundtracks. While Shelly’s extensive discography is amazing. The list of musicians he has played, or recorded with is literally mind-boggling.
Read moreReflections on Shelly Manne: Chapter 5
Not So Modern Drummer columnist David Barsalou asked internationally recognized drummers – Billy Drummond, Larry Finn, Tim Griffin, Rod Morgenstein, Alphonse Mouzon, and Lewy Stix
to share their ideas and opinions on the following quote attributed to Shelly Manne.
Shelly Manne said...
"The ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play".
Read more
Mike Clark: Words of Wisdom part8
Once you’ve mastered a lot of the technical wizardry that your heroes have played, you only have a small piece of the puzzle...That’s the easy part.
When you age, and hear the phrasing they played when they were twenty years younger makes you realize where the real work is!
Read moreReflections On Shelly Manne: chapter 4
NSMD's David Barsalou asked internationally recognized drummers Claire Arenius, Marko Djordjevic, and Dave DiCenso to share their ideas and opinions on the following quote attributed to Shelly Manne: "the ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play".
Read moreReflections on Shelly Manne: Chapter 3
“Anyone can learn to play a jazz ride cymbal beat. The problem is making it swing. Shelly Manne's mentor was Davey Tough and to go back to listen to the early recordings of Woody Herman's ‘First Herd’ with Davey Tough playing drums, says it all. It's all about swing”.
Read moreReflections on Shelly Manne, Part 2
NSMD’s David Barsalou asked internationally recognized drummers Bill Goodwin, Gordy Knudtson, Gregg Potter, John JR Robinson, Terry Silverlight, Todd Sucherman, and Paul Wertico to share their ideas and opinions on the following quote attributed to Shelly Manne.
Shelly Manne said...
"The ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play".
Read moreMike Clark: Words of Wisdom - Part 7
Best Drummer In The World? Who can orchestrate and swing like Elvin Jones? – Nobody. Who changed everything for everybody and came up with a new way of looking at things like Tony Williams? –Nobody.
Read more
Billy Ward - Journey of the Group
Any words of advice for players who are pursuing a life in music? "I'm happy you said "life in music" as opposed to "career in music". I think careers in music have lessened - but interaction with youtube and such websites has made it easier to communicate. People can make a record in their home now! My only advice is to do it because you HAVE to and can't live without it. If somebody does it for fame and fortune they will be sorely disappointed. Be as best a musician as possible - study MUSIC, not just drumming.
Read moreGeorge Lawrence -Liner Notes for Poco's 2013 CD "All Fired Up"
I am not a legendary drummer, but I did play in a legendary band, so that's why I included this piece that I wrote about that legendary band in this Legendary Drummers category. Legendary!
Originally published March 2013. This is the liner notes I wrote for our album All Fired Up which was released march 2013. They were not used because there were no liner notes, though the first sentence was used in one of our press releases. "There is no manual for a forty five year old rock band........."
Read moreReflections on Shelly Manne - Chapter One
Not So Modern Drummer asked five distinguished drummers to share their ideas and opinions concerning the following quote attributed to Shelly Manne, "The ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play."
Read moreRhythm Retreat: Billy Cobham, Dave Weckl and Steve Holmes
Study with world class players in a world class setting! Drumming takes you on an amazing journey. Now there’s a way to take your journey further. Come experience Rhythm Retreat®—an exclusive getaway for those passionate about drumming.
IMMERSE YOURSELF AT OUR NEXT EVENT IN NEW YORK'S FAMED FINGER LAKES:
Billy Cobham Dave Weckl Steve Holmes
Ithaca, NY - August 30th through September 4th, 2015
Each all-inclusive Rhythm Retreat getaway package offers:
- Full-day instruction with each clinician
- Luxury lodging at a refined inn
- Daily travel to/from hotel, restaurants and recreation
- All meals, snacks and beverages
- Unique nighttime recreation
- Private group dinners with clinicians
6, 4 and 3-day packages available. Spouses and companions allowed. Restrictions apply.
For more information, visit: www.rhythmretreat.com
Bob Girouard: Never Give Up
In my high school study hall, I was reading the latest issue of Downbeat featuring Max Roach, Frank Capp, and Bobby Colomby who were featured on the cover. Bob Girouard noticed it immediately and asked if he could check it out. That very 1960s moment was the beginning of a lifelong friendship… We started talking drums, and the rest is History.
"Bob is an inspiration for all of us. His career has covered a lot of ground and his drive and love of drumming is something we can all learn from." - Rob Wallis
Over the years, I have seen Bob go through good times and bad. Musicians know the struggles to succeed. Bob understood this perfectly, yet never gave up. When stricken with Parkinson’s disease in 2003, the challenge became even greater. With each passing day, the God given drumming talents that Bob possessed were slowly fading away.
Previous to being diagnosed, Bob worked steadily with a number of successful groups. His greatest notoriety came with the band Forest. They toured on the East Coast circuit with a potent line-up of truly amazing musicians. At one point they were ready to sign with MCA records. A sudden change in company management caused the deal to fall through. It was a painful moment for the band so Forest took the master tapes and released their album independently. Although recorded in the 1970’s, their music remains fresh and vibrant to this very day. They were recently featured on the Atomic radio network with a Forest retrospective, coupled with live interviews. Based on listener calls, Forest’s album continues to be popular in both Germany and Japan.
I first met Bob Girouard when I was The Band's Road Manager in the 1990s. Bob worked for the City of Albany promoting cultural events. Being a drummer, Bob of course loved Levon Helm. Bob truly believed in the Brotherhood of the Drum, and still does to this day. He would book any band that Levon was part of, out of love and respect, plus a strong desire to be near Levon and Randy Ciarlante, our second drummer. His incredible devotion to drummers, drumming and good music is legendary in our circles. As Levon got sick, and our bookings dropped off, due to the fact that he wasn't singing Band songs, Bob never wavered. He would book Levon and the Barnburners (Levon's blues band) whenever he could. Oftentimes this helped Levon pay his mortgage. As Bob got sick himself, and his ability to drum waned, he took up writing about drummers. His devotion and loyalty to the brotherhood of the drum stayed strong. As my late friend Richie Hayward got sick, Bob wrote eloquently to help Richie's cause. After Richie passed Bob's eulogy was the most touching I ever read. Levon's health also declined and, whenever possible, Bob's writing would boost Levon's spirit and help in his struggle to live. Bob's devotion to drumming and drummers wasn't reserved for the big stars. Bob championed lesser known drummers, and always promoted quality music everywhere. Now Bob has resumed drumming even after brain surgery, and during his life's struggles. I, and the Brotherhood of the Drum, salute Bob Girouard's courage, strength and devotion.
Long may he wave.
Respectfully & Gratefully Butch Dener The Band (ret.)
A large contingent of upstate New York bands gathered to honor Bob with a fundraiser- “Boogie for Bob” to help defray his medical costs. The remaining portion, was donated to the Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Disease research.
Over 300 people attended the venue to help the cause. All the groups donated their performances.
“Boogie For Bob” featured:
- Hair of the Dog: Famed Irish, roots and rock band, and a major draw in the Northeast.
- Aged in the Hills: A Country institution since 1978 *Note: This was Bob's first drumming affiliation when he moved to NY from Mass. in 1986. The band charted in the top 20 nationally with the single, "Cafe Romance," B/W "Cajun Two-Step."
- Ernie Williams Band: In honor of the late "Ambassador of the Blues", they performed. Ernie was a fixture on the local/national blues scene for decades...opening several times for the recently departed, B.B. King.
- Blues House Rockers: Featuring the creme de la creme of blues musicians in the Albany, New York region. They have played with blues/rock icons Little Feat, and Delbert McClinton.
- Diva and the Dirty Boys/Urban Gumbo: An exciting blend of the best traditional R&B musicians w/classic covers, then morphing into Urban Gumbo, segueing into songs from the brand new 2015 album, "Hard Times for Love”, (of which Bob co-produced and played drums).
- Forest: Throughout the 70s one of New England's most critically acclaimed bands. A mainstay in clubs, colleges, and concert halls… It was an original sound that meshed the popular genres of the era: blues, rock, country and jazz, a hybrid between the Allman Brothers, Doobie Bros, Steve Miller, and Steely Dan, with some of the finest musicians to ever come out of Western Mass. Musically, no matter what he's done since, Bob's history begins and ends with this band. According to Bob: "They'll never be another band like Forest...the brotherhood, the musicality, and the respect between each other as people."
Bob played and sang a few tunes throughout the show, although his condition made it difficult, His sheer determination helped him get through it. The event was a fitting tribute to a musician who continues to be loved by many.
"An excellent musician and accomplished writer...THE G-MAN RULES!! I'm proud to call him one of my best friends..." - Dino Danelli
As Bob’s disease continued to advance, he was determined to find another way to stay musically involved. He began writing for Classic Drummer, and Elmore Magazine, and is now writing for Modern Drummer; In 2013 he wrote the cover article on Dino Danelli. Another gathering of Forest alumni is scheduled for later this year, and all proceeds will be donated to the foundation for Parkinson’s research.
Bob Girouard is more determined than ever to keep on fighting. Even after recent brain surgery and a daily regimen of numerous medications, music is a constant presence in his life; he continues to remain optimistic about the future.
With a friendship that goes back over 45 years, Bob recently requested this author become a permanent member of the Forest family.
Musical Artists Interviewed by Bob Girouard: (2005-present)
- Carmine Appice ( drummer, Vanilla Fudge, Rod Stewart)
- Max Weinberg ( drummer, Bruce Springsteen, Conan O’Brien
- Kenny Aronoff (drummer, John Mellencamp, John Fogerty)
- Brian Auger (Brian Auger’s Express)
- Charlie Adams drummer,(Yanni)
- Ray Benson (Asleep at the Wheel)
- Johny Barbata (drummer, The Turtles, Jefferson Airplane)
- George Brown (drummer, Kool & The Gang)
- Clem Burke (drummer, Blondie)
- Pete Best (original drummer, The Beatles)
- Hal Blaine (Session/drumming great: The Beach Boys, The Righteous Brothers, Sonny & Cher, etc.)
- Gary “U.S.” Bonds (R&B Great)
- Deborah Bonham( sister of Led Zeppelin’s John Bonham)
- David Brigati (vocalist, Joey Dee and the Starlighters)
- Eddie Brigati (vocalist, The Rascals)
- Paul Barrere (guitarist/vocalist, Little Feat)
- George Frayne (Commander Cody of Commander Cody & his Lost Planet Airmen)
- Jeff Chonis (drum technician to Ringo Starr, drummer for The Beatles)
- Doug Clifford (Creedence Clearwater Revival’s drummer and now CCR Revisited)
- Aaron Comess (drummer, The Spin Doctors)
- Gene Cornish (guitarist, The Rascals)
- Bobby Colomby (producer/drummer: Blood Sweat & Tears)
- Larry Campbell (multi-instrumentalist/band leader Levon Helm Band)
- Felix Cavaliere (organist/lead vocalist, The Rascals)
- Mickey Curry (drummer, Bryan Adams)
- Micky Dolenz (drummer/vocalist The Monkees)
- Kal David (guitarist/vocalist The Fabulous Rhinestones)
- Burleigh Drummond (drummer, Ambrosia)
- Liberty DeVitto (drummer, Billy Joel)
- Dennis Diken (drummer, Smithereen’s)
- Dino Danelli (drummer, The Rascals)
- Grahame Edge (drummer, The Moody Blues)
- Steve Gadd (drummer, Paul Simon, James Taylor, Eric Clapton)
- David Garibaldi (drummer, Tower of Power)
- Sandy Gennaro (drummer, teacher: Cyndi Lauper, The Monkees, Pat Travers Band)
- Steve Gorman (drummer, The Black Crowes)
- Richie Hayward (drummer, Little Feat)
- Levon Helm (drummer, vocalist, actor: The Band, Levon Helm Band)
- John Hiatt (singer, songwriter)
- Brendan Hill (drummer, Blues Traveler)
- Graham Hopkins (drummer, Motion Picture and Broadway musical, “Once”)
- Don Imus (Radio & TV Personality)
- Jai Johanny Johanson “Jaimoe” (drummer, Allman Brothers Band)
- Kenney Jones (drummer, The Faces, The Who)
- Harold Jones (drummer, Tony Bennett, Lady Gaga)
- Simon Kirk (drummer, Free, Bad Company)
- Jim Keltner (drummer, George Harrison, Joe Cocker, The Travelling Willbury’s)
- Gordy Knudtson (drummer, Steve Miller Band)
- Russ Kunkel (drummer, James Taylor, Carly Simon, Linda Ronstadt)
- Will Lee (bassist, David Letterman Show, The Fab Faux)
- Terry Lickona (producer, Austin City Limits TV Show)
- Corky Laing (drummer, Mountain, Corky Laing’s Memory Thieves
- Chris Layton (drummer, Stevie Ray Vaughn & Double Trouble
- Lyle Lovett (musician, actor)
- Jim McCarty (drummer, The Yardbirds)
- Sir Paul McCartney (The Beatles, Wings)
- Delbert McClinton (R&B Great)
- Neil Peart (drummer, Rush)
- Slim Jim Phantom (drummer, Stray Cats, Dead Men Walking)
- Prairie Prince (drummer, The Tubes)
- Shawn Pelton (drummer, Saturday Night Live)
- Dick Peterson (drummer, The Kingsmen)
- Simon Phillips (drummer, Jack Bruce, The Who, Pete Townsend, Toto)
- George G. Receli (drummer, Bob Dylan)
- Cathy Rich (daughter of Buddy Rich and owner of Buddy Rich drum company)
- Paul T. Riddle (drummer, Marshall Tucker Band)
- Rick Shlosser (drummer, Boz Scaggs, Juice Newton)
- Tommy Shannon (bassist, Stevie Ray Vaughn & Double Trouble)
- Denny Seiwell (drummer, Paul McCartney & Wings)
- Paul Shaffer (keyboardist, composer, musical director, David Letterman Show)
- Yonrico Scott (drummer, Royal Southern Brotherhood)
- Gina Schock (drummer, The Go Go’s)
- Danny Seraphine (drummer, Chicago, and California Transit Authority)
- Neal Smith (drummer, Alice Cooper)
- Floyd Sneed (drummer, Three Dog Night)
- John Steel (drummer, The Animals)
- Ronnie Tutt (drummer, Elvis Presley, Roy Orbison)
- Fred Tackett (guitarist/vocalist, Little Feat)
- Roger Taylor (drummer, Queen)
- Butch Trucks (drummer, Allman Brothers Band)
- Derek Trucks (guitarist, Tedeschi-Trucks band)
- Steven Van Zandt (guitarist/vocalist/actor, Bruce Springsteen and the E. Street Band, Little Steven’s “Underground Garage,” The Sopranos)
- Chris Vatalaro (drummer/percussionist, Antibalas, Bat for Lashes, Imogean Heap, Brian Eno)
- Rob Wallis (CEO Hudson Music)
- James (“The Worm”) Wormworth (drummer, Jimmy Vivino and the Basic Cable Band) Conan O’Brien TV show
Mike Clark: Words of Wisdom, Part 6
Chapter six in an ongoing series of commentary from legendary drummer Mike Clark. His storied observations continue to inspire, and provide keen insight into ‘all things music’.
I was lucky my Mom loved jazz. At age five I would bring my Gretsch Broadcasters into the kitchen while she was cooking, play for her and she loved it. The neighbors would say, “how can you stand that noise”? She would say, “what noise”? He sounds like Gene Krupa.
My other heroes were Zutty Singleton, Cozy Cole, Lionel Hampton, Big Sid Catlett, Louie Bellson, and Buddy Rich. At eight I discovered Art Blakey.
My experience with Herbie Hancock happened when he became emotionally involved, and it was on the real. It was the most inspired and highly spirited music...Definitely not for the faint of heart. He would bring this to any genre...It was like John Coltrane as far as power, energy, emotion, and dialogue...Herbie is from that school in my humble opinion...Deepness Reigns!!
Don’t you just love it when you lose something and someone says -where did you lose it? If I knew that, I would know where it is and it wouldn’t be lost!
BB King… It is going to be weird without him. I am just so used to that sound. I know we can hear the music, but he has always been there. I’m glad I got to meet him.
BB King once asked the Headhunters to play a tune with him. Everybody plays some deep stuff trying to show BB they can play the blues. Hancock plays some totally avant-garde solos like something you would have heard on an Eric Dolphy record in 1963. After his solos BB takes the microphone with a confused look on his face and says…”Well, everybody has their own way of playing the blues”.
I once realized there was something missing deep in my life.... so I bought a cowbell!!
Mike Clark: Words of Wisdom, Part 5
Chapter number five in an ongoing series of commentary from legendary drummer Mike Clark. His storied observations continue to inspire, and provide keen insight into ‘all things music’.
---
I played double drums on a gig with Lenny White once and he took a solo all poly-outness while I held my place quietly on the 2 and 4. He took it so far out I was hanging on for dear life. But Lenny was right, and here is the kicker...I was proud of myself for keeping my place. But he was the dude that played everything. It was amazing, as Lenny knows where he is at all times… But it really sounded like he modulated into about 80 different time signatures at once.
I love Art Blakey’s playing, his bands, arrangements, his groove… When it comes to swingin’ – Is there anyone that can swing harder? Not for me.
Does anybody but me get tired of seeing and hearing the same 6 or 7 guys playing all the festivals and jazz joints over and over? Who's idea is that? Or if there is a new guy… He has to make up some wild way of playing that most of us had thought of and discarded.
When I play swing no matter how far out I go, I play it on the 2 and 4. Same with funk… No matter where I put the backbeat, the "Thing" if you will is on the 2 and 4. That’s what I do.
I remember when you had to play several different styles of jazz… Usually a few you really liked best. It was hard to make a living specializing in one area unless you had really good luck. Now it’s hard to make a living playing any of those styles. Now I see that several guys stay in one bag for a lifetime and do OK. For me, that would be like eating eggs every morning forever.
Elvin Jones said he wanted to be part of the scene, but didn’t want to play in a conventional way. Elvin really didn’t hear that, and he was severely criticized for it. Being with Coltrane solidified his concept, and his words. How would things be if he didn’t have the good fortune to get that gig? How would things sound today?
I went to a mix when Tony Williams played, I was listening to the playback and the time sounded a bit soupy, Tony walked by the board and pushed the fader up to the top and the track swung incredibly, and it sounded like Tony. The engineer cried and whined about the fact that it red lined. Tony said, “the red line - that’s how jazz is supposed to sound”.
I admit it - when I played with musicians having great careers, I would be kind of nervous since I wanted what they had. While playing with Herbie Hancock, there was none of that. He was so famous I guess my brain processed it differently. In the last five years I’m finally over it. I really enjoy playing with anyone, no matter how much they’ve got. As long as the music is cool… That’s the end of it…I am actually in the moment. It took a lifetime… But better late than never!
When mixing drums for jazz, I would suggest listening to some old Blue Note records as many times as possible. Now the drums are compressed like a pop record and the tuning seems to be in between what used to be jazz tuning and pop or fusion. Also, the groove is in the ride cymbal… So don't turn it down and have it sound like mush.
Mike Clark: Words of Wisdom, Part 4
Drummers who use traditional grip...Some people use the index finger over the stick along with the second finger etc. or some guys use the thumb as it is a strong appendage, or kind of open which they used to call rabbit ears...I really think all have certain advantages so why use just one?
OK, My humble opinion. To have a James Brown movie without mentioning Fred Wesley’s name, is like making a John Coltrane film and not mentioning Elvin Jones.
Drummers who want to play jazz, or whatever you want to call it… Check out ‘Do The Math’, an interview with Billy Hart. He talks about history, and his history…The ride beat, which drummers did what, and all kinds of great stuff for musicians who love this music.
Can never stop paying my debt of gratitude to...Philly Joe Jones, Papa Jo Jones, Max Roach, Elvin Jones., Tony Williams, Art Blakey, Tootie Heath, Mickey Roker, Billy Hart, Billy Higgins, Roy McCurdy Lenny White, Kenny Clarke, Gene Krupa, Buddy Rich, Clyde Stubblefield, Louie Bellson, Sonny Payne, Sam Woodyard, Louis Hayes, Jabo Starks, Dave Garibaldi, Bernard Purdie, Clifford Jarvis, and Joe Chambers.... I think about what these cats did and why everyday...Many more, but it would take forever.
Lenny White and I are working on a book about what it was like when he was with Return to Forever, and I was with Herbie Hancock. It also addresses many other things… Even though I lived it, I enjoy the proofing as I’m learning from reading it. At any rate, it’s way cool...Not just drum talk…There’s so much more.
Shelly Manne said…“The ride beat is the easiest and the most difficult thing a drummer will ever play”…Or something like that.